There are certain statements men and women should never make to each other. These statements are relationship killers of the worst kind. For men that statement is in the form of the following: "I like you like a brother" and the "He's too nice" statement. On the latter hangs this tale of a romance nearly doomed. (Ok, I'm sure you are wondering about the statement that women hate... but you know the one that men give you thats called The Promise. Being a man, I'm not going to get into that one at this time.)
I have a friend that complains about the lack of men in her life. She complains about their shortcomings in great details. This one is too short, that one is too boring, but the worst one that she complains about is the one thats TOO NICE. Hmmm... now most "nice" guys really hate to hear this. What the heck is TOO NICE? When I asked her what was "TOO NICE and what was wrong with it... she looked perplexed and after screwing up her face and biting her lips just answered that it was too hard to explain. For the sake of this story we will call her Ms. Staken. She is a witty, beautiful, sometimes self-absorbed, caring and intelligent woman.
Now Ms. Staken was currently dating two men. The first man (we will call him Cupcake) was a gentle guy, possessed of a paying job, good manners, and inquisitive natured. He was thoughtful and kind, loved children and went through life with the notion that people are basically nice and wonderful. The second man (lets call him Fruit Loops) was just the opposite... sports nut (you know the type... paints his face in the team colors even at home watching a game), scratches himself at the most inopportune times, hates anything cultural unless its the history of beer making, find kids annoying, hates to dress up and hates to to talk about anything more pressing then the box scores. Also he works...sometimes..when the mood strikes him because "he wants the freedom to explore life"!
When Ms Staken goes out with Cupcakes, he takes her to a nice place to eat, never minds going to places she like to go, even if its not his thing and seems genuinely interested in the things that makes her who she is. He doesn't press and is not annoying. When she goes out with Fruit Loops it can be an exciting blend of erotic entertainment that he likes, places to eat that don't require much in the way of reading like a menu with more then two syllables, and hanging out with friends so he can show her off since he describes her as "his babe". So when we sat down one day to help her figure it all out it was an eye opener. I've been the Mr. Nice Guy type and for the life of me I can't understand whats wrong the being NICE!
Me: So which one will you choose and why are you going out with Fruit Loops in the first place?
MS: Well, he is sooo bad...exciting, you know!
Me; Actually I don't...enlighten me!
MS: Women like those guys that are on the edge and he is definitely an edgy guy, exciting and most of the time fun to be around... when he is not too drunk or when a game is on.
Me: And Cupcake?
MS: Well he's....
Me: boring?
MS: No...he's (here it comes) TOO NICE!
Me: Too Nice? What's that suppose to mean? You've been going out with him twice as long as Fruit Loops.
MS: Yeah, but it hard to explain.
Me: He's not as exciting or are you a thrill junkie?
MS: (Screwing up he face in concentration) Noooo...you'd have to be a woman to understand!!!
Me: BS. Been hit over the head with that NICE title plenty of times. So you mean to tell me that you'd rather end up with a guy that treats you like dirt and a plaything then someone that can see to your needs and really try to understand what you are all about?
MS: Well, no...he[Fruit Loops] is not someone I'd want to marry or anything like that...but a women needs that excitement once in a while. I mean why do guys go out with women with big boobs....
Me: Don't go there...
MS: He just ticks me off because he won't do anything with his life. Ok I confess he is a bit of a bum but a cute bum.
Me: And Cupcake?
I notice a change of expression on Ms. Staken's face... a softening of line and hint of a smile at the corners of her lips.
MS: He's always the perfect gentleman and really knows how to treat a lady. Fun to talk with and you know...just be with. Its frustrating...
Me: What?
MS: I mean I could totally walk all over this guy...
Me: Try it.
MS: What?
Me: Try to walk all over him.
MS: Be serious.
Me: I am. You think because he is gentle and and quiet that it would be a walk in the park to pulls his strings like a puppet. If you try you'd be in for rude awakening. And how about the romance?
MS: Pervert! Well..hmmm...I can't complain about either of them on that score but I'm not saying anymore about that. Its just I'm getting older and my biological clock is ticking...you know.
Me: Get digital.
MS: Ass! And I mean that in the nicest way. Anyway I need to choose...
Me: Well have you told Fruit Loop that he needs to get his act together?
MS: Well not in so many words...I mean I don't want to disturb his game or anything. He did promise that we would have a serious talk...
Me: When was that?
MS: Ok, it was months ago. But you can't pin a guy like that down. Don't want to pressure him or anything.
Me: And Cupcake? What have you told him?
MS: Nothing. Its just hard to get a handle on him in that respect. I mean he's really, really NICE and I don't want to scare him off.
Me: (Eye rolling in my head). Thats the dumbest thing I've ever heard from a supposedly intelligent woman.
MS: Hey, it ain't easy for a woman these days. I suppose I should at least find out where he stand huh?
Me: Might be worth the effort. You might even find that he's, well, NICE about it!
MS: You know you can be a real ASS sometimes!
Me: I'm a man...so sue me!
MS: Fruit Loops isn't so bad. Maybe I can teach him a few thing and get him to chance a bit!
(WARNING, WARNING Will Robinson...) Ok, men are not furniture or dolls that you can play dress up with. Ken was a wimp anyway. Most men will change when they are good and ready... if at all and women are only deluding themselves if they think otherwise. The good men will learn the great art of compromise... and thats as far as they will go. Besides after you finish your "changing" project, you probably won't be interested anyway because that person will not bear any resemblance to the person you were attracted to in the first place.
Me: Ok, you still haven't told me why you think Cupcake is TOO nice. Is he boring?
MS: No, never boring... it just... well he's too...
Me: Nice?
MS: Yep... its tough to explain.
Me: Ok, let me make a stab at it. Too nice means that he is not, nor will he ever be, a project for a makeover or you feel in-adequate because he's got his shit together and you don't! It happens you know!
MS: Damn, you've good...!
Me: Been working around women toooooo long...and I'm NEVER nice!
Last week I received an invitation to a wedding stting that "We would like your company at the joyous occasion of the marrige of Ms Staken and...."